Tateh's Great Escape

    In E.L. Doctorow's Ragtime, the motif of "escape" appears in many places and in many ways throughout the story. In fact, one of the most central ideas the book repeatedly explores - the near-omnipresent optimism in the "American Dream" at the dawn of the 20th century - closely relates to this central motif. At the core of that belief was the thought that anyone could succeed, regardless of their social status or any other characteristics, hence, "escaping" from societal constraints. The stories of almost all characters in Ragtime relate to this motif of escape too, whether they do so literally (like Houdini,) figuratively, or through a mix of both. Several characters' lives also include elements of the American Dream as well, moving up from situations where it sometimes seemed like the odds were completely stacked against them to become extremely successful and wealthy people (except for J.P. Morgan, of course, who is so disgustingly rich that nothing will satisfy him except escaping the bounds of mortality itself.)

    There is one character in Ragtime, though, that clearly exemplifies this combination of the motif of escape with the idea of the American Dream. That character is Tateh (and, to an extent, his daughter too.) Tateh and his daughter were Jewish immigrants who left their home country to seek a better life in New York. But not everything is going well for him and his daughter when Evelyn Nesbit first meets them. He is an incredibly skilled artist ("He began to create more and more intricate silhouettes, full-figured, with backgrounds [...] Most of these are today in private collections." (Doctorow, 45),) yet works on a street corner unprofitably selling his portraits for 15 cents each. And he lives in a filthy tenement where he struggles to take care of his daughter after divorcing his wife for having sex with her boss in exchange for money ("His own wife, to feed them, offered herself and he has now driven her from his home and mourns her as we mourn the dead." (Doctorow, 43).) All of this information shows the incredible difficulty of the situation Tateh finds himself in and the stress and guilt associated with his current way of life. It seems as though he wants desperately to leave, but his pride won't let him. Even when offered money, he refuses to take it; he is dead-set on only escaping his situation through his own efforts.

    Due of this, later in the book, Tateh attempts to escape multiple times from the conditions that lower-class people found themselves in during this era. First, overwhelmed by grief and guilt over his wife ("The little girl quietly prepared their simple meals in ways so reminiscent of the movements of his wife that finally he could bear the situation no longer," (Doctorow 90)) he packs up everything he and his daughter own and spends much of his savings to "escape" from New York by rail. As for where he's going, he simply doesn't know. He just can't stand living in New York anymore. But after this incredible multi-day journey, he just finds himself in a Massachusetts textile mill where he is overworked and underpaid while living in a cramped, dirty tenement no different from the one he occupied back in the Lower East Side. Eventually, unsatisfied with their situations (like Tateh before) the workers at his factory go on strike. Tateh joins them despite some internal conflict, but a plan to move the children of those workers out of town for their safety goes wrong, causing police to swarm the train station the workers had gathered at and forcing Tateh to once again mount a hasty escape to save his daughter. 

    This time they arrive in Philadelphia, and it is here that Tateh's luck seems to change for the better. Tateh walks past a Franklin Novelty Company shop while exploring downtown Philadelphia with his daughter. But some force drives him to linger outside the window even while his daughter walked on. He decides to enter, and on a whim demonstrates the flipbook of an ice skater he created back in Massachusetts to an employee of the company. Within the hour, he enters into a contract to publish that book, and four more over time, with the company, instantly becoming richer than ever before. His success is not short-lived, either; later in the book, it's revealed that he spins his skills as an artist into a lucrative career as a filmmaker. Finally, he is able to enjoy life with his daughter without worry. He is his own boss, and has escaped from the cycle of abuse and poverty that has defined his life up until this point. And he can treat his daughter, at last, in the way he's always wanted to: "Come, Tateh said to his child, we'll find a boardinghouse in a good neighborhood and then we'll have ourselves a meal and a hot bath." (Doctorow 133)

Comments

  1. I like how you frame Tateh's eventual deal with the Franklin Novelty Company as a win, and an escape from the cycle of abuse. I think it's amazing that he is able to make money for himself and do what he loves, after escaping his home country, the New York slums, and the abusive millhouse, but I always feel vaguely that something is lost from the end of Tateh's story. He is able to succeed. He doesn't have to do anything corrupt to do it, but it is only when he separates himself from the working class that he is able to make this change. This emphasizes that what happens tom him is a one-off because of a fluke and his particular skills. He can live the American Dream, but only when he gives in and accepts a path that does not associate him with his fellow workers, further bringing home the point that it is impossible for workers at that time to have a good standard of living.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Tateh seems like the character in this novel who most embodies this "American Dream" ideal of escape from the circumstances of one's birth in order to "rise" in society--and he does follow the Houdini model in many ways (a foreigner who changes his name to something more appealingly "exotic" as a way to frame a career in entertainment; an artist who is inventing new expressive forms that respond to the historical moment, etc.). If we consider and compare the ways the novel "leaves" these two characters, though, the irony seems more strongly directed toward Houdini: we last see him in the midst of a yet-imcomplete escape, dangling absurdly over the streets of Manhattan while a random New Yorker (on brand!) curses him out from a window. Tateh, in contrast, is established with his new multicultural/diverse family, in a comfortable stucco home on the West Coast, facing an optimistic future after getting in on the ground floor of one of the dominant industries of the twentieth-century. There have been a few other escape artists in the tradition of Houdini over the years (David Blaine is maybe the most prominent example), but we can't say that "escape artistry" has become anything like a dominant artform of the century. Film, on the other hand . . .

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Aldo! Super interesting blog, dog! I love how much the themes of escape and success tie into each other in Ragtime. ESPECIALLY with Tateh. I find it so fascinating that he almost "escapes" his old life to achieve success, but he never really escapes it. In what way do you think irony ties in with all of this? Because I think it also played a key role in this story.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Aldo, I really liked how you tied in the idea of escaping with Tateh's journey throughout the book. While at first Tateh and Houdini seem to be quite different, like others mentioned the both of them were Jewish immigrants who managed to work their way up the system. In fact, out of all the characters in the book, these two seem to have the most satisfying endings, which is nice since they each truly earned their positions themselves, and the American Dream was proved to be possible. Overall, great post!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Aldo, I enjoyed reading the simplicity of your writing; making your argument very clear. You also use strong evidence from the novel to back up each point, especially with Tateh and his daughter journey from poverty to success. I also like how you connected his struggles with the broader motif of escape and the American Dream. One suggestion I have is that you could show how their story direction contrasts with other characters(like Coalhouse, Younger Brother, or Houdini), since that would highlight how escape doesn't look the same for everyone in the novel. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's exactly what I'm doing in my short essay :)

      Delete
  6. I think it's really interesting how you frame Tateh as a success of the American dream, also the quote at the end. Personally, I wonder whether it can be a success of the American dream if the way he achieved his success was-- as you put it-- luck. More strict to the story, his achieving of success only happened once he left behind industry works (ie, stopped doing lower class work). So, my question is: can it be called an American dream if it is not through America's pre-established systems that promise promotion, rather through invention, that he gets his dream? Also, I think the Ford model is an interesting display of the inescapability of industry works, so displaying this escape of a similar system is really interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Aldo, I really like how you compared Tateh's success and escape from poverty and trying to have the American dream. the escapes of Houdini. You really showing the struggles that Tateh and his daughter had to go though and how hard they had to work. It shows Tateh's resolve to make sure his daughter can live the American dream. I really liked this post.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey Aldo, I enjoyed how in your blog you chose to write about Tateh's whole journey and your point it being tied to an escape with the American Dream. It's very cool how you didn't choose to just follow one escape, but several to better show how each one gets him closer to a better life. I think it's interesting how his big "success" doesn't happen until he decides to leave the working class life behind, which makes me contemplate Doctorow's potential commentary of how the American Dream isn't possible unless you step out of the system. Wonderful post!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Aldo, I really enjoyed reading your blog. I think that your choice to analyze Tateh and his trying to escape was a great one. Even though I think other characters are also trying to escape, like Houdini, for example, I really liked how you only focused on one character because I think that you got a lot of good detail out of it. Good job.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Add a comment...